Blogging for Dollars?
My friend, Melissa, recently wrote this post, expressing her frustration with the small circle of bloggers who seem to be getting all the perks.
I read it and left a lengthy comment, then realized I had even more to say.
So, here it goes.
I have been feeling some stress and increasing negativity in bloggyland lately.
Unrest among the masses regarding PR, "A List" (whatever that is) Mommy Bloggers, the lack of money in blogging, etc.
I've personally considered withdrawing completely and have spoken to a few other bloggers who are also feeling somewhat "disenchanted" with blogging as of late.
It seems to have lost its luster.
Here is how I see it:
You begin blogging for fun.
For connections.
For camaraderie.
You get a few followers and comments.
You want more.
You begin to see others talking about the free stroller or set of books.
You want that too.
Then you hear that some are getting to travel, meet with PR firms, speak at conferences.
That sounds fun.
You wonder, why not me?
As a blogger who has a blog that generates some income, will be speaking at a conference (so what if it's my own conference, still counts, right?) and is paid to work with a PR Firm, I want to give you the low down.
The way I see it.
Take it or leave it.
1. Contrary to popular belief, unless you are Dooce or Pioneer Woman, there is no real money in blogging. Some of you are incredibly talented writers. You work on your blogs daily. Hours of time crafting posts, coming up with blog fodder, agonizing over what to post next or why your pageviews are dropping. Stop. It doesn't matter. Even if you made $100/month, would it be equal to minimum wage when you added up the time spent? In the scheme of your life, do pageviews really matter?
Here is some perspective, Chic Chick Media (made up fo 4 blogs, 1 being SITS) gets over ONE MILLION combined pageviews each month and sells ads for $75/month. Split between 4 blogs.
2. Most PR firms and brands have not figured out the true value of "mommy bloggers" and they never will as long as someone is willing to do it for free. The PR firm that does Fishful Thinking got my involvement for two reasons: A. Fishful Thinking is a great program, not a product. It's something I am thrilled to be part of and has personally improved my parenting and enhanced my life. B. They compensate me for my time, offered real training and truly wanted input from the moms involved.
I receive "pitches" all the time. I choose not to participate, as unless they are offering monetary compensation for MY hard work and prime "bloggy real estate", I'm not interested in making them money. My choice. I have no problem with review blogs, but I rarely read them.
3. Most PR firms and brands do not look beyond pageviews. Until they start matching bloggers to brands, we will continue to see the same women representing the brands. How many times have you seen an ad on a particular blog and wondered, "What the hell were they thinking?". There is one blog in particular that has me scratching my head every time I see a new ad.
4. Women are often each others worst enemies. We will find any reason to be outraged at one another. Jealousy is alive and well in bloggyland. We won't share our secrets or tell the truth when it comes to our contacts, stats, income, etc.
5. So even after the above, you still want to be a Queen Blogger- (whatever that means) Here is my 2 cents. If the popular girls at your high school went to another high school, would they still be popular? Probably not. We make them "A List" by giving them pageviews. For a great blogger, I am thrilled to do this. Happy to give her my "business" in clicks. She has earned it. For a blogger who baits traffic by causing drama and linking it up- not so much. Want to stop giving drama queens traffic? Stop linking to their drama-ridden posts. Spend your time getting your blog out there. Educating yourself on how SEO works. Network, promote yourself- that's what they did.
So here is my final piece of advice.
Blog if it brings you pleasure.
Enhances your life.
Makes you smile.
It IS a choice.
Unless it's making you over $40,000 a year, it's not worth 40 hours a week.
If you come by here one day, and this blog is gone, don't worry about me.
I'm fine.
Just ready to move on.
No, I am not planning to take my blog down anytime soon, but if it was all gone tomorrow, I'd shrug my shoulders and move on.
Happy with the friends I made, the laughs I shared and the lives I peeked into.
I read it and left a lengthy comment, then realized I had even more to say.
So, here it goes.
I have been feeling some stress and increasing negativity in bloggyland lately.
Unrest among the masses regarding PR, "A List" (whatever that is) Mommy Bloggers, the lack of money in blogging, etc.
I've personally considered withdrawing completely and have spoken to a few other bloggers who are also feeling somewhat "disenchanted" with blogging as of late.
It seems to have lost its luster.
Here is how I see it:
You begin blogging for fun.
For connections.
For camaraderie.
You get a few followers and comments.
You want more.
You begin to see others talking about the free stroller or set of books.
You want that too.
Then you hear that some are getting to travel, meet with PR firms, speak at conferences.
That sounds fun.
You wonder, why not me?
As a blogger who has a blog that generates some income, will be speaking at a conference (so what if it's my own conference, still counts, right?) and is paid to work with a PR Firm, I want to give you the low down.
The way I see it.
Take it or leave it.
1. Contrary to popular belief, unless you are Dooce or Pioneer Woman, there is no real money in blogging. Some of you are incredibly talented writers. You work on your blogs daily. Hours of time crafting posts, coming up with blog fodder, agonizing over what to post next or why your pageviews are dropping. Stop. It doesn't matter. Even if you made $100/month, would it be equal to minimum wage when you added up the time spent? In the scheme of your life, do pageviews really matter?
Here is some perspective, Chic Chick Media (made up fo 4 blogs, 1 being SITS) gets over ONE MILLION combined pageviews each month and sells ads for $75/month. Split between 4 blogs.
2. Most PR firms and brands have not figured out the true value of "mommy bloggers" and they never will as long as someone is willing to do it for free. The PR firm that does Fishful Thinking got my involvement for two reasons: A. Fishful Thinking is a great program, not a product. It's something I am thrilled to be part of and has personally improved my parenting and enhanced my life. B. They compensate me for my time, offered real training and truly wanted input from the moms involved.
I receive "pitches" all the time. I choose not to participate, as unless they are offering monetary compensation for MY hard work and prime "bloggy real estate", I'm not interested in making them money. My choice. I have no problem with review blogs, but I rarely read them.
3. Most PR firms and brands do not look beyond pageviews. Until they start matching bloggers to brands, we will continue to see the same women representing the brands. How many times have you seen an ad on a particular blog and wondered, "What the hell were they thinking?". There is one blog in particular that has me scratching my head every time I see a new ad.
4. Women are often each others worst enemies. We will find any reason to be outraged at one another. Jealousy is alive and well in bloggyland. We won't share our secrets or tell the truth when it comes to our contacts, stats, income, etc.
5. So even after the above, you still want to be a Queen Blogger- (whatever that means) Here is my 2 cents. If the popular girls at your high school went to another high school, would they still be popular? Probably not. We make them "A List" by giving them pageviews. For a great blogger, I am thrilled to do this. Happy to give her my "business" in clicks. She has earned it. For a blogger who baits traffic by causing drama and linking it up- not so much. Want to stop giving drama queens traffic? Stop linking to their drama-ridden posts. Spend your time getting your blog out there. Educating yourself on how SEO works. Network, promote yourself- that's what they did.
So here is my final piece of advice.
Blog if it brings you pleasure.
Enhances your life.
Makes you smile.
It IS a choice.
Unless it's making you over $40,000 a year, it's not worth 40 hours a week.
If you come by here one day, and this blog is gone, don't worry about me.
I'm fine.
Just ready to move on.
No, I am not planning to take my blog down anytime soon, but if it was all gone tomorrow, I'd shrug my shoulders and move on.
Happy with the friends I made, the laughs I shared and the lives I peeked into.
Comments
Will you think it odd if I squeal when I meet you?
Big hug and sloppy wet kisses. Cause I know you like 'em.
I don't agonize over my blog posts. Sometimes they're funny, sometimes sad, mostly they involve photos of my kids (my main audience is friends and family). I LOVE that I have made some real-life friends through my blog. I am NOT looking to make an extra dollar.
Would I object if someone gave me a bunch of money because they loved my blog so much? Heck no.
Is it gonna happen? Um, most likely never.
We may not be the "popular" girls, but we are the girls who stand by each other, being friends and loving each other through it all.
I'm here to write. To share my writing with others. To read other bloggers. I'll read blogs that are giveaways to a certain extent but if that's all they do, I quickly unfollow them. I can appreciate what they're doing but I'm here for a different reason, I guess. It's great people can make money blogging but it sounds like a whole lot of work for very little payoff. I've done a lot of mystery shopping and, to be truthful, it sounds like there's more payoff in THAT for a SAHM than blogging. My inbox is constantly filled with mystery shopping offers I can't even take. Just Google mystery shopping and see what's out there. Just a tip!
I'm not saying it's fair or that they are the best writers, but that's the way it is. If a "new" blogger dreams of the same perks, she'll have to put in her time and fight against hundreds of thousands of other mommy bloggers to stand out. The odds are slim.
You're right Tiffany. We should blog because we love it, or wrap it all up and go home. There's no real income to be made from a modest mommy blog!
As for my personal blog, I love to write. I just love it. I came to the conclusion a long time ago that the numbers come and go and you have to be okay with that.
And no drama. I hate drama.
i have to stop stressing over the stuff that i never cared about before.
excellent post honey!!!
i can't wait to meet you!!!
xoxo
I certainly don't mind the reviews and the chance to win something (usually for my boys), but I'll be honest, I skip over the reviews a lot of times. I don't have time to read all of that, let alone ever do it myself.
I like using my blog for it's original purpose: meeting others (especially other moms), updating my friends on my life, and raving (or ranting) about my husband or my kids. It's therapy for me. I don't take the time to plot out my thoughts usually unless it's for a special occasion like a birthday or anniversary. :) But I always appreciate the comments I get from you and my very few other readers. They're genuine and I feel like I've made some genuine friends.
The why am I blogging? I have to admit that my passion has died somewhat and I've been blogging much less. I used to spend countless HOURS on it last winter, and I wonder why? I'll continue to blog if only to maintain some of the beautiful friendships I've developed over the last year.
But, in the end, what DOES it all mean? I didn't sell out to be a popular girl in school and won't do it now. I still do what I love on my blog and have never received a dang thing but bloggy love and some new friends along the way.
This is enough for me. I spend about 2 hours a week on my blog. Done.
On the internet, I can chat with friends from the comfort of my living room while my children play.
If I make $5 from it...then BONUS!
I'm going to SITScation...because I think I'm a good blogger and I want to meet other good bloggers. And it's VEGAS baby!
I think blogging is a fun way to mee pepole and get a glimps into the way others live. I have met many friend trhu blogging and keep up with my frinds and familys life that live far away.
I have noticed the trend of everyone becomeing a blogg full of adds. That really turns me off from reading them.
I have been askd to put adds on my blog but I refuse. I dont want to fall into the trap of othes that I av een that once had really personal ad cute blogs that now write another way becaue they are getting paid a few bucks to advertise.
BTW I do love reading your blog it always makes me laugh.. Or think..
Thans for keeping it real..
Just my opinion to each his own, do what makes you happy. I'm just not into all that.
Geez people is it that serious?
Would love to know which blog keeps you scratching your head?
:)
I like my follwers and feel like they like me because we converse. I don't give a shit about products. None of them are worth much anyway.
Pageviews will come and go. The numbers game will always be a rollercoaster.
My blog is NOT my life but ABOUT my life. Therefore, I have finally learned not to spend so much time worrying about it.
I will probably never, ever, ever place a single AD on my blog.
And I have finally learned how to promote myself within myself. If it works great. If it doesn't, oh well.
But I can't wait to learn more at the conference. I still enjoy blogging and conversing with others out there. I have also had to re-prioritize my blog reader. I needed to think about what I was truely enjoying and what I was just following to fit in.
Great post!
I have to continually remind myself of why I started it, and what is and is not important.
Thanks for sharing this....
I would find myself comparing and trying to "be" like other bloggers. I started making excuses. I work full time and have other things I need to do, etc. Then I realized, that if doesn't bring me joy, it's silly to do it. So, I am on hiatus and until I know I can blog and not worry about traffic or comments, it's staying that way. Right now, I am just a blog reader.
Thanks for the post and for making me feel a little better about stepping back.
I went and read the post you linked, and the other that she linked.
At first I'm thinking, why does it bother her so much. Then I remembered that it's her blog and she can complain if she wants to. Whatev.
But on the subject of disenchantment, I think it's the same thing when you meet your mate. You have to give it a good couple of years to get to know the "real" them, not just the them they want you to see. In this case the them is blogging.
It all seems nice and sweet and wonderful in the beginning and then you get to know that nothing is 100% THAT nice, sweet or wonderful.
So, like you said, do it if it makes you happy and if it doesn't then don't. But don't expect that you'll get money or fame from it. I'm thinkin you have a better chance of winning the lottery. WHICH I'm still waiting for by the way. Damn Mega millions jipped my ass. AGAIN!
I totally loved this post. Loved it.
But I have to tell you. If you just disappeared one day to move on, I'd really, really miss you. Wait. I have your phone number. And your email address. So I could still stalk you, right?
Jamie :)
Oh, and I would stomp all over Dooce in a blog off. That's right, I said it. I ain't scared!
Well said.
but this is precisely why I have not signed up for adspace on my blog, at least not for the moment
I just blog for me. the fact that others seem to actually be interested enough in what I have to say to follow me and comment is truly humbling...but it really is just gravy :0)
And drama? Please. I don't do drama in real life, I don't want to deal with it here either!
Thanks for this :0)
Stopping in from SITS! Thanks for posting this! I'm not one of those woman who get jealous and love to create drama. never have been. don't have time for it! :-) And to those woman I quote the country song:
"God is great....beer is good...and people are crazy!"
LOL!! :-)
How many times have you and I already talked about this subject? GREAT POST, m'dear.
I applaud you.
I am actually thankful that I love to cook and my posts come from there and that's it. Out of that, I have made some beautiful friends who actually make my days and make me feel like a complete woman. Sometimes I am in a funk in the morning and tell myself to visit a few gals to see what they're up to. After, I always feel better. I just never go where the negativity is.
I kid, I kid.
In all seriousness, I blog for fun, for friends, and for family. The connections and comments are nice and fun and give me warm fuzzies. I'll leave it at that for me.
Very, very well written post.
(BTW, I just came back from a 3-week hiatus, and it was kind of nice.)
My blog did kind of take off out of control when I was fortunate enough to be named a Blog of Note by Blogger. For awhile I found myself trying to tap dance for all my new followers and give them a good reason to stick around. Then I stopped freaking out and realized that the blog they saw when they hit that follow button is the same blog they are seeing now. If they like me, SUPER! If they don't that's ok. I do love hosting giveaways for my readers so I participate a couple of times per month in a review or two. I did just get my first "real" ad today. It was quite exciting, I must admit.
Even though my blog is hopping I still do what I want how I want to and I try my best to steer clear of drama and BS. I am here to express myself and create friendships and I am blessed to have accomplished both!
Great post! Hope you are doing fantastic!
E
I started my blog out of curiosity and to get my mind away from grief of a loss and then I came across SITS. It has been the best part of my blogging experience thus far.
Every once and a while I read a post that stays with me for ever. This is one of those.
Thank you.
Also, please don't go. Bloggy land needs your wisdom and honesty.
I get a little annoyed myself when people just review things. I don't read the posts. I don't enter the giveaways. I click away and stop going to visit as much : )
Thank you for writing this!!
Just three words for ya Tiffany: Please Don't Go.
:)
Very well said Tiffany. Thank you.
I blog because I love it. If I get a little something extra it's just the icing on the cake, but NOT the reason for my blogging.
i blog b/c i love to. b/c its my little home here on the web... i don't blog for money, nor things (if i do a review it's b/c my hard earned money was spent on the product and i thought it was worth mentioning)... i blog just b/c its flat out fun...
wonderful post...
XOXO!
I didn't and don't expect to make tons of money blogging. I actually started blogging so that I can eventually make them into a book for my daughter. I just want to leave a little piece of me with her when I am gone some day. And if my blogging helps others, then it makes me feel good!
For what it is worth, I like your blog and I like the SITS blog. I think you have done a great job on both counts.
Chat with you later! Have a great day!
AWESOME!
Blogging should be about sharing oneself with others and connecting.
But you are doing such a great job. I hope you don't get too disheartened by things around, and you don't give up!
I for one am very encouraged by this post. :) Thanks!
Loved it. Every last word of it. Amen and Hallelujah.
I've been working on my blog, getting it set up so it's more user friendly. Because I *do* want feedback. And if someone comes along who wants me to check something out and wants to give me some perks in between? Okay. I like compensation.
But I could never see myself making my blog all about the benjamins. It's an outlet, it's a release, a showcase, and it's for me. Trying to turn it into a "job" that is clearly more fraught with frustration and bullshit than originally anticipated would only add tons of stress that I really don't need.
I love the sense of camaraderie and finding people so I know that I'm not alone on days when I'm feeling just a tad bit off the wall.
I make no money off my blog. I write because I love the people I come across. I don't feel all alone in my thoughts. I honestly thought I was the only one who hated Crocs. But I wrote an entry about it and found out that there are dozens more who agree with me. It was exciting, really...
I'm stopping by from Moxie Media. I'm trying to check out all the blogs :)
As are you...
Also well said...and high time somebody said it.
xoxo
Sheri
http://sherisstory.blogspot.com
http://miraclemomas.blogpsot.com
That was just so freaking well-said. Thank you.
I love blogging and that will never change. But at the end of the day, I never started blogging to make money.
Except when I wrote in my journal..i didn't get to read other's..and so that is what blogging is like to me...a peek into other people's lives..other moms..and it's pretty cool.
I have been approached by 3 companies and they were VERY honest with me...this is what they said
We want to use your blog for it's PR IF you will link to us you can pick something from so n so site for this amount of money, there is no need to blog about our site just a link will suffice...I was LOL cuz they were honest...
anyways i thought this post was awesome, i so wish i was joining you ladies in Vegas!
I think you're absolutely right. Women can be each other's worst enemies. I still don't quite know why we do it to each other, but it happens. And as soon as I start seeing that happening somewhere in the blogoverse, I disappear. I have better things to do and better blogs to read.
Kristin
If someone called and said, I want to advertise on your blog and the product was something that I already loved that promoted the mission of my blog, I'd say, "Sure." Otherwise, I'd say, "No thank you." I've had the opportunity to do that once, though.
I blog because I've wanted to have a column for years about what being the mother of 5 sons has taught me. I figure other moms need a little encouragment along the way like I did and do.
I've got more out of blogging that I ever imagined, in terms of reading blogs that uplift and encourage.
It allows me to write about what I think for my children when maybe they won't want to hear it now, but they will later.
Thanks for your candid post. Maybe you need to review your mission statement, re-establish a new mission.
Cristina
Now, I'm off to educate myself on how SEO works. Thanks!
Lynn
Because of this post - I am a follower now.
Looking forward to reading more!
Thanks for SITS!!!
I'm fairly new to blogging, but not to writing. I was a successful TV-Movie writer for nearly two decades, made all kinds of money, but honestly, my blogging has given me more pleasure than my TV work ever did. It's enabled me to actually enjoy writing again and I've met so many wonderful writers and bloggers. I've read many posts on blogging and this one of yours really nails it. I'm thrilled when I get new followers and thrilled with the comments they leave, but only because it is giving me an audience to do what I love and get feedback on it. I know of nowhere a writer can have this kind of intimacy with an audience except maybe on the stage. I enjoy your blog because, although you bill yourself as a mommyblogger, you write about other things as well, and your writing is clear, precise and most of all -- spell-checked! I will start to follow you if I can just find the follow button now. Thanks for a great read. - Jayne,